Problem
Let
ABC
be a triangle, and let
M
and
N
be the midpoints of
AB
and
AC,
respectively. Let
K
and
L
be chosen strictly inside triangles
BMC
and
BNC,
respectively, such that
K
lies strictly inside triangle
ABL
and
L
lies strictly inside triangle
AKC.
Suppose that
∠KBA=∠ACL,∠LBK=∠LNC,∠LCK=∠BMK.
Let
O
be the circumcenter of triangle
AKL.
Prove that
OM=ON.
Solution
Let
A′
be the reflection of
A
in
O,
so
O
is the midpoint of
AA′.
Since
M
and
N
are the midpoints of
AB
and
AC,
respectively, a midpoint calculation gives
OM=21A′B,ON=21A′C.
It is therefore enough to prove that
A′
is equidistant from
B
and
C.
Coordinates
forced by the interior conditions
Use the oriented basis
b=B−A,c=C−A.
The strict-interior hypotheses imply that
A,B,C
are not collinear, so the oriented area
[b,c]
is nonzero. Positive barycentric coordinates obtained from
K∈int(BMC)
and
L∈int(AKC)
give numbers
kb,kc,lb,ld
such that
K−A=kbb+kcc,L−A=lbb+ldc.
To make the inequalities transparent, write
L−A=λ(K−A)+μc,
where
λ,μ>0
and
λ+μ<1.
Then
lb=λkb
and
ld=λkc+μ.
The coordinates of
K
in
BMC
similarly give
kb,kc>0
and
kb+kc<1.
Consequently
0<kb<1,0<ld<1,kbld−kclb>0.
Indeed, the last determinant equals
kbμ>0.
Put
ν=1−λ−μ>0
and
Δ=[b,c]=0.
The condition
K∈int(ABL)
also gives
K−B=α(A−B)+β(L−B)
for some
α,β>0.
Directly expanding the six oriented areas in the basis
(b,c)
now gives
[K−B,A−B][L−B,K−B][L−C,K−C]=kcΔ,=αldΔ,=νkbΔ,[A−C,L−C][L−N,C−N][B−M,K−M]=lbΔ,=2lbΔ,=2kcΔ.
Every displayed coefficient is positive. Therefore the two angles in
each of the three given equalities have the same oriented sign. Equality
of their ordinary angles can consequently be upgraded, without a sign
ambiguity, to
∡KBA=∡ACL,∡LBK=∡LNC,∡LCK=∡BMK.
Translating the
angle and circle conditions
For two ordered pairs of nonzero vectors, equality of their oriented
angles gives the division-free identity
[r,s]⟨u,v⟩=[u,v]⟨r,s⟩,
where
[u,v]
denotes the oriented area of
u,v,
and
⟨u,v⟩
denotes their Euclidean inner product. Expanding every ray in the basis
(b,c),
the three oriented-angle equalities therefore produce three polynomial
identities in
kb,kc,lb,ld
and the three Gram-matrix entries
⟨b,b⟩,⟨b,c⟩,⟨c,c⟩.
More explicitly, identify a coefficient pair
(α,β)
with the vector
αb+βc.
In each of the following rows, the four entries are the coefficient
pairs of
(u,v,r,s)
in that order:
((kb−1,kc),(−1,0),(0,−1),(lb,ld−1)),((lb−1,ld),(kb−1,kc),(lb,ld−21),(0,21)),((lb,ld−1),(kb,kc−1),(21,0),(kb−21,kc)).
These are respectively the rays in the three oriented equalities
above, expressed in the common basis. For
i=1,2,3,
let
Ei
be the left-hand side minus the right-hand side of the
determinant-inner-product identity after substituting the
ith
four-tuple. Thus
E1=E2=E3=0,
and all three equations follow by direct bilinear expansion, without
dividing by an inner product or tangent that might vanish.
Put
z=A′−A.
Because
O
is equidistant from
A,K,L,
expanding
OA=OK
and
OA=OL
gives
⟨z,K−A⟩=∥K−A∥2,⟨z,L−A⟩=∥L−A∥2.
Define
CKCL=⟨z,K−A⟩−∥K−A∥2,=⟨z,L−A⟩−∥L−A∥2.
Then
CK=CL=0.
Direct expansion and collection of terms gives the polynomial
identity
(2kblb+3kbld−kb+kclb+2kcld−kc−lb−ld)E1+4(kb+kc)(1−ld)E2−4(lb+ld)(1−kb)E3+2(1−kb)(1−ld)(lb+ld)CK−2(1−kb)(1−ld)(kb+kc)CL=(1−kb)(1−ld)(kbld−kclb)⋅(2(⟨z,b⟩−⟨z,c⟩)−(⟨b,b⟩−⟨c,c⟩)).
The left-hand side is zero because all five defining equations
vanish. Therefore
(1−kb)(1−ld)(kbld−kclb)(2(⟨z,b⟩−⟨z,c⟩)−(⟨b,b⟩−⟨c,c⟩))=0.
The first three factors are strictly positive by the
interior-coordinate inequalities. Hence
2(⟨z,b⟩−⟨z,c⟩)=∥b∥2−∥c∥2.
Expanding squared norms now yields
∥z−b∥2=∥z−c∥2.
Since
z−b=A′−B
and
z−c=A′−C,
this is exactly
A′B=A′C.
The midpoint observation at the start then gives
OM=ON.